Managing commodity price risk in volatile markets

Uncertainty and volatility have been hallmarks of essential meals and beverage commodity markets for the previous a few yrs. The COVID-19 pandemic gave way to intense worldwide provide chain disruptions, and right now, businesses are going through inflationary pressures not viewed in the previous 40 many years. Commodity chance management has always been a essential ingredient of business, but throughout these hard moments, it is really important to equally have an understanding of and manage commodity charges.

To efficiently manage commodity charges, one should get started from the foundation that futures markets are generally priced on the fundamentals of offer and demand from customers. From there, one particular can estimate a array of practical selling prices.  

For grain and oilseed markets, this is expressed in Carryout/Use ratios and Times of Offer calculations.  Some markets are a lot more sensitive to tightening shares than other folks.  Wheat, for case in point, is considerably extra delicate to lower Carryout/Utilization levels in contrast to corn and soybeans.  Once you realize the sensible prospects of carry out/use ratios for any given current market, and their historic cost ranges, you will have extra self-confidence and achievements coming in less than price range and taking care of commodity value chance.

Let us start off with historical price tag ranges.  Below is a chart of corn prices likely back to 1960.   You can see in the 1960s and into the early 1970s, corn traded in a array of $1.00 to $2.00 for every bushel.  When inventory/utilization tightened, corn tested $2.   When the US had too considerably corn, it traded to $1.00.  That cost dynamic adjusted for the duration of the 1970s and the Good Inflation period.  Corn typically traded amongst $2.00 and $4.00.   The cost range lasted till 2006-2007.

So, what transpired about 2006-2007?  The Renewable Gasoline Specifications Act was introduced in 2005 and expanded in 2007.  The US experienced to change from making 11 billion to 12 billion bushels of corn a 12 months total to 15 billion to meet up with the increased demand from customers brought on by the RFS.  At the exact same time, China was shopping for important quantities of soybeans from the US and that led to corn (ethanol) and soybeans (China) competing for acres.

After the earlier two years of inflation, you can make the situation the marketplaces are in a new value period.  The days of $3 corn, $4.50 wheat, and $7 soybeans may possibly be extensive long gone.  While not as poor as the 1970s, we have seen a cumulative raise of 15% inflation considering that 2021, owing to COVID shutdowns and subsequent stimulus.   Soybean and canola oil are about to turn out to be a additional substantial aspect of US inexperienced vitality plan and may well change price ranges better for oilseeds the same way ethanol did for corn. 

CBOT corn futures chart

The upcoming factor to comprehend is Carryout/Use ratios (a very similar concept to Days of Offer). What is viewed as plentiful, enough, and tight for just about every current market? Listed here are some equations that may well assistance in determining every single marketplace predicament.

Carryout/Utilization = Ending Carryout Shares / Overall Utilization

Days of Offer = Ending Carryout Stocks / (Overall Use/365 days)

Let us say corn has 1.5 billion projected ending stocks and a complete yearly utilization of 15 billion bushels.

Carryout/Use = 1.5 bil bu / 15. bil bu = 10%

Times of Supply = 1.5 bil bu / (15. bil bu / 365 days) = 36.5 days of source

Carryout/Utilization tells us how significantly still left-over offer we have at the close of the internet marketing yr as a proportion of overall desire.  Days of Supply tells us how many days of normal use we have still left more than at the finish of the advertising year, ideal just before harvest starts.

Now that we know the historical rate ranges and how to determine Carryout/Use, we can appear at previous several years and see how costs are inclined to trade.  You will recognize in the chart under when Carryout/Usage is 10% or lessen, regular farm prices for the 12 months may well be above $5 for each bushel.  When Carryout/Use is previously mentioned 12% the ordinary farm selling price is usually beneath $4 per bushel.  

What these two charts and the Carryout/Use calculation exhibits is corn is tight at 10% or reduced and burdensome at 12% or larger.  If you did the identical assessment for soybeans, you would see 10% or lessen Carryout/Usage is limited, 10-15% is satisfactory, and around 15% is extremely burdensome/bearish.

Wheat, on the other hand, starts tightening when Carryout/Usage is between 30% and 35% and Times of Offer are about 120, which is practically 4 months.  

Why is wheat so a great deal far more sensitive to tight stocks when when compared to corn and soybeans? 

The majority of wheat shares is made use of for human usage whilst the the vast majority of corn and soybeans are made use of for feed and energy.  If corn and soybeans tighten, you can decrease on animal feed and ethanol/renewable biofuels.   85% percent of domestic wheat usage is applied for human intake. 

Wheat is also a single of the least expensive caloric solutions for humans.  If we have a scarcity in wheat, we have a big food stuff disaster on our palms.   That is why the sector is much a lot more delicate to wheat shortages over corn and soybeans, and why 30% Carryout/Utilization is regarded as limited for US wheat shares while 10% is viewed as restricted for corn and soybeans.

The essential piece of the puzzle is creating a model for offer (acres and produce) and need (exports and domestic use).  Supply and need totals almost never vary additional than 5% calendar year about year, so you can produce some quite responsible parameters for possible price ranges specified we never have a historic drought to slash offer or a pandemic to crush demand from customers.  

From there you can use a combination of value targets and time triggers to get protection for commodities all through the budget year.  Food and beverage corporations can use monetary hedges this kind of as alternative collars, with the probable superior as the prolonged call and the feasible lower as the small set.  You may perhaps also use About the Counter  (OTC) structured goods to set caps on prices for finances functions and set hedges to accumulate price coverage at value areas on a weekly basis prior to your spending plan calendar year.  We discover that when our clientele understand the feasible price tag ranges for the 12 months primarily based on bullish and bearish Carryout/Utilization situations, procurement teams are extra most likely to use money tools to enable manage their commodity expenditures.

Deciding upon the Right Husband or wife

You want a firm that is aware of your sector – and is familiar with your marketplaces. With more than 100 years of experience in the commodity marketplaces, StoneX (NASDAQ: SNEX) checks the two containers. We work with your corporation to optimize buying possibilities and regulate the inherent cost dangers as nicely. By controlling your commodity fees to the maximum regular, StoneX is much more than just a financial services company—we are your lover. Collectively, we can drive your company’s upcoming development.